Shakhnazaryan N. ., Ermolin D. S. Neighborship and Rescue Stories in a Comparative Perspective: the Conflicts in Kosovo and Karabagh

Nona R. SHAKHNAZARYAN — Candidate of Historical Sciences, Institute of Archaeology and Ethnography of the National Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Armenia (Armenia, Yerevan); Centre for Independent Social Research (Russia, St. Petersburg)

Denis S. ERMOLIN — Candidate of Historical Sciences, Peter the Great Museum of Anthropology and Ethnography (Kunstkamera) of the Russian Academy of Sciences (Russia, St. Petersburg)


 Download  |  Go to Issue #4. 2019


ABSTRACT. The study belongs to the academic genre of anthropology of neighborship and everyday life and provides a retrospective analysis of complex paths of neighbors’ relations in one of the former Soviet republics (Azerbaijan) and an autonomous region of the former Yugoslavia (Kosovo). The authors look into such social phenomena as rhetor forms, representations of recognition and non-recognition, friendship and hatred in the neighbors’ relations in the face of ethnic cleansing and pogroms, their behavior and motivation of rescue agents. The descriptions of unparalleled violence can most often be qualified as difficult-to-talk- about traumatic narratives related to the “conflict”, problematic individual memory. However, eyewitness accounts demonstrate that humane acts also took place, in most cases by neighbors who chose the difficult path of opposing the ill will of the vengeful crowd. Studying the social and political context in which Azerbaijanis and Albanians shielded Armenians and Serbs from danger, we articulated many factors and actors of the social game. The major factors are the cultural meanings of such notions as neighborhood, urban landscapes, provinciality, competition for the access to social benefits and the new-rich culture. These concepts, which took the form of institutionalized practices, with the increase of the emotional tension of pogrom trends and violence, played more and more significant roles in both Karabagh and Kosovo conflicts.

KEYWORDS: Azerbaijan, USSR, Kosovo, Yugoslavia, ethnic conflict, neighborship, escape

УДК 323.1
DOI 10.31250/2618-8600-2019-2(4)-68-99


  • Akhapkina Ya. E. [Province, Periphery — Nomination Problem]. Provintsiya kak real’nost’ i ob’yekt osmysleniya [Province as a Reality and Object of Reflection]. Tver: Tver State Univ. Publ., 2001, pp. 6–12. (in Russ.).
  • Arendt H. Banal’nost’ zla. Eykhman v Iyerusalime [Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil]. Moscow: Europa Publ., 2008. (in Russ.).
  • Astvatsaturian Turcotte A. Nowhere. A Story of Exile. 2012. (in English). Bataković D. Twentieth-Century Kosovo-Metohija: Migrations, Nationalism, and Communism. Journal of North American Society for Serbian Studies, 1999, no. 13 (2),
  • pp. 1–23. (in English).
  • Behrends J. C. War, violence, and the military during late socialism and transition. Five case studies on the USSR, Russia, and Yugoslavia. Nationalities Papers, 2015, vol. 43, no. 5, pp. 667–681. (in English).
  • Cabanel P. Protestant Minorities, Judeo-Protestant Affinities and Rescue of the Jews in the 1940s. Resisting Genocide: The Multiple Forms of Rescue. London: Hurst, 2010, pp. 433–445. (in English).
  • Ćirković S. Stereotip vremena u diskursu raseljenih lica sa Kosova i Metohije [Stereotype of Time in the Discourse of Displaced Persons from Kosovo and Metohija]. Belgrade: Balkanoloshki institut SANU Publ., 2012. (in Serbian).
  • Durkheim E. Samoubiystvo: Sotsiologicheskiy etyud [Suicide: Sociological Etude].
  • Moscow: Mysl’ Publ., 1994. (in Russ.).
  • Göçek F. M. In Search of “The Righteous People”. Resisting Genocide: The Multiple Forms of Rescue. London: Hurst, 2010, pp. 33–50. (in English).
  • Horowitz D. L. The Deadly Ethnic Riot. Berkeley: Univ. of California Press, 2001. (in English).
  • Hovannisian R. G. Intervention and Shades of Altruism during the Armenian Genocide. The Armenian Genocide: History, Politics, Ethics. New York: Palgrave Macmillan Press, 1992, pp. 173–207. (in English).
  • Hovannisian R. G. (ed.) The Armenian Genocide: History, Politics, Ethics. New York: Palgrave Macmillan Press, 1992. (in English).
  • Kaestli E. Hendeqe dhe Ura. Miqёsitё nё Ballkan para dhe pas luftёrave. 16 portrete [Ditches and Bridge. Friendships in the Balkans before and after the Wars. 16 portraits]. Pristine: Qendra pёr Hulumtime dhe Politikё Gjinore Publ., 2005. (in Albanian).
  • Kapustina E. L. [Rural Etudes to the Urban Landscape: the Transformation of Urban Space in the Context of Migration in Dagestan and the Fate of Rural Communities in Makhachkala, the Beginning of the 21st century]. Kavkazskiy gorod: potentsial etnokul’turnykh svyazey v urbanisticheskoy srede [Caucasian City: the Potential of Ethnocultural Relations in the Urban Environment]. St. Petersburg: Museum of Anthropology and Ethnology of the RAS, 2013, pp. 111–175. (in Russ.).
  • Kostovicova D. Kosovo: The Politics of Identity and Space. London, New York: Routledge, 2005. (in English).
  • Mann M. The Dark Sides of Democracy: Explaining Ethnic Cleansing. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 2005. (in English).
  • Martynova M. Yu. [Ethnic Factor in the Fate of Kosovo]. Kosovo: proshloye, nastoyashcheye, budushcheye [Kosovo: Past, Present, Future]. St. Petersburg: Aleteyya Publ., 2013, pp. 82–135. (in Russ.).
  • Marutyan H. The Issue of the Rescue of Armenians by Ottoman Subjects during the Armenian Genocide. Journal of the Society for Armenian Studies, 2017, vol. 26, pp. 39–61. (in English).
  • Mosesova I., Ovnanyan A. Vandalizm v Baku [Vandalism in Baku]. Yerevan: Gitelik Publ., 1991. (in Russ.).
  • Naimark N. M. Fires of Hatred: Ethnic Cleansing in Twentieth-Century Europe. Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press, 2001. (in English).
  • Naimark N. M., Case H. (eds.) Yugoslavia and Its Historians: Understanding the Balkan Wars of the 1990s. Stanford: Stanford Univ. Press, 2003. (in English).
  • Oganezov G., Kharatanyan G. (comp.) Samooborona armyan Kirovobada v 1988–1989 gg. glazami ochevidtsev [Self-Defense of the Armenians of Kirovobad in 1988–1989 Eyewitness Eyes]. Yerevan: National Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Armenia Publ., 2014. (in Russ.). Oliner S., Oliner P. The Altruistic Personality: Rescuers of Jews in Nazi Europe. New York:
  • The Free Press, 1988. (in English).
  • Shahnazarian N. Breaking the Nation’s Taboo. The Meds Yeghern and Turkish Intellectuals.
  • PONARS Eurasia Policy Memo, 2009, no. 86, pp. 1–5. (in English).
  • Shahnazarian N., Ziemer U. Young Soldiers’ Tales of War in Nagorno-Karabakh. Europe- Asia Studies, 2012, vol. 64, iss. 9: Many Faces of the Caucasus, pp. 1667–1683. (in English).
  • Shakhmuradyan S. (ed.) Sumgaitskaya tragediya v svidetel’stvakh ochevidtsev. Kniga pervaya [Sumgait Tragedy in Eyewitness Accounts. Book 1]. Yerevan: Armyanskiy fond kul’tury Publ., 1989. (in Russ.).
  • Shakhnazaryan N. [Child soldiers of the Karabakh War: Life Stories of a Militarised “Youth”]. The Journal of Power Institutions in Post-Soviet Societies (PIPSS), 2008. Available at: (accessed: 13.04.2019). (in Russ.).
  • Shakhnazaryan N. [Salvation as an Analytical Category: Righteous Altruists or Calculating Dealers?]. Analitikon [Analyticon], 2015 (April). Available at: http://theanalyticon. com/?p=6210&lang=ru (accessed: 12.04.2019). (in Russ.).
  • Shakhnazaryan N., Shakhnazaryan R. [“Show Me Respect”. Discourses about the Parallel Economy, Kinship, and Corruption in Caucasian Communities]. Laboratorium: Russian Review of Social Research, 2010, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 50–72. (in Russ.).
  • Shnirel’man V. A. Voyny pamyati: mify, identichnost’ i politika v Zakavkaz’ye [Wars of Memory: Myths, Identity and Politics in Transcaucasia]. Moscow: Akademkniga Publ., 2003. (in Russ.).
  • Suthana N., Fried I. Percepts to Recollections: Insights from Single Neuron Recordings in the Human Brain. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 2012, no. 16, vol. 8, pp. 427–436. (in English). Ternon Y. The Impossible Rescue of the Armenians of Mardin. Resisting Genocide: The
  • Multiple Forms of Rescue. London: Hurst, 2010, pp. 383–394. (in English).
  • Zejneli Z. Kosovska svakodnevnica [Kosovo Everyday Life]. Niš: Prosveta Publ., 1995. (in Serbian).